What we do
Tools
Industries
Department
How we workLet's talk →
Home/QuickBooks/QuickBooks vs Square
QuickBooks vs. Square

QuickBooks vs. Square: Which One Does the Job You Need Done?

Both take card payments and both have invoices, which is why they get compared. But Square is built to run the moment of the sale, and QuickBooks is built to keep the books afterwards. Most businesses that sell in person end up with Square at the counter and QuickBooks behind it.

The short answer

Selling at a counter, a table or a market stall? You need a point of sale. That's Square's home ground.

Need a profit and loss, a balance sheet, or books your accountant can file from? That's QuickBooks. Square's reports are sales reports, not accounting.

Doing both? Use both and connect them. Intuit's own Square connector handles the basic sync, covered in Square integration with QuickBooks.

What each one is actually for

Square

Runs the sale

  • Registers, card readers, kiosks and table-service setups, all on one item catalog.
  • Item-level sales, inventory counts, staff and tips at each location.
  • Simple invoices and online checkout for customers who don't come in.
  • No general ledger: it can't give you a balance sheet or track what you owe and own.
QuickBooks

Keeps the books

  • Double-entry accounting: profit and loss, balance sheet, cash flow.
  • Bills, vendors, payroll, sales tax and bank reconciliation in one place.
  • Can take cards too, on invoices and in person through its GoPayment app and card reader.
  • Not built to run a busy counter: no kitchen tickets, table layouts or self-order kiosks.

So it's rarely Square or QuickBooks. The real question is whether Square alone is enough for now, and if not, how the two share data.

Which setup fits a business your shape

Your business Start with Watch for
A market stall or side business, card and cash only, one owner Square on its own, with its sales reports Tax time. Someone still has to turn Square's reports and your other expenses into real figures for the return.
Consulting, trades or services, billed by invoice QuickBooks on its own Whether you ever take payment on the spot. QuickBooks' own payments may cover it without adding a POS.
A shop, cafe or salon with staff and a counter Square at the counter, QuickBooks for the books, connected How sales arrive in QuickBooks. A lump "Square Sales" line hides which items or services make money.
Several locations or product lines, inventory that ties up real cash Both, plus a sync that carries location and item cost Cost of goods sold. Square knows what sold, QuickBooks knows what it cost, and margin needs both in the same place.

Signs Square alone has stopped being enough

Your accountant rebuilds your year from Square exports

How you'll know: Every spring someone downloads Square reports and bank statements and pieces the books together.

Fix: Move the books to QuickBooks and connect Square, so sales and fees land there through the year instead of all at once.

A lender or landlord asks for financial statements

How you'll know: You can show sales totals but not a balance sheet or a profit and loss.

Fix: That needs accounting software. Square's sales reporting doesn't track loans, assets or what you owe.

You can't say which products actually make money

How you'll know: Sales look strong, but cash doesn't, and you don't know which line is carrying the others.

Fix: Book cost of goods sold against what each sale contained. The story below shows what that took for one retailer.

Connected, and still guessing at margin

Retailer · Square at the counter, QuickBooks for the books, three product lines

Before

The official connector already synced Square payouts into QuickBooks without trouble.

The owner still couldn't say which of three product lines was profitable. Square reported sales by item, QuickBooks reported revenue by payout, and nothing put item-level cost next to item-level sales.

After

n-frames built a layer on top of the existing sync that posts cost of goods sold for the exact items in each Square transaction, instead of a flat estimate.

The profit and loss the owner already pulled every month now shows which product line carries the other two.

Questions people ask

Is Square better than QuickBooks?

For running a register, yes. For accounting, QuickBooks is. They do different jobs, which is why many businesses pay for both rather than picking one.

Can Square replace QuickBooks for accounting?

Only for a very small, simple business, and only for a while. Square's reports show sales, but they're not double-entry books and won't produce a balance sheet an accountant, lender or tax preparer will accept.

Can QuickBooks process payments like Square does?

Partly. QuickBooks Payments takes card payments on invoices and online, and in person through the GoPayment app and a card reader. What it doesn't give you is a full point of sale for a busy counter, with item modifiers, table service or a self-order kiosk.

Do I need to connect Square and QuickBooks if I use both?

Not strictly, but without a connection someone re-enters Square's sales and fees by hand. Square Connector by QuickBooks automates the basic sync. Businesses that need sales split by location, or margin by product, add a custom layer on top of it.

Let's talk

Tell us the one thing your team does manually that eats up time. We read every message and reply within a day.