What we do
Tools
Industries
Department
How we workLet's talk →
Home/Stripe/Stripe Dispute
Stripe

Got a Stripe Dispute? What to Do Before the Deadline

The cardholder's bank has already pulled the money and a fee from your Stripe balance. You can accept the loss or counter it with evidence, and you get exactly one submission. Here's how to decide, what to send, and what it costs either way.

Right now

Open the dispute from the Disputes list in your Dashboard. The details page shows the reason, the amount and your response deadline.

Payments Disputes

You usually have 7 to 21 days, depending on the card network. Miss it and the dispute is lost automatically.

Choose Counter dispute or Accept dispute. Countering opens a guided form. Once you submit, you can't edit it or add files, so gather everything first.

What a dispute costs, win or lose

Stripe charges a fee when the dispute arrives and a second one if you counter. The countered fee comes back if you win. The received fee doesn't, unless your contract says otherwise.

Example · $120 order, US account, countered and lost
Disputed amount, held from your balance (Returned only if you win) − $120.00
Dispute received fee (Charged either way) − $15.00
Dispute countered fee (Refunded if you win) − $15.00
Total out of pocket if you lose − $150.00

Fees differ by country, so check Stripe's pricing page for yours. Win that same case and you'd be out only the $15 received fee. On a small order, accepting can cost less than countering, which is why Stripe offers a Workflows template that accepts disputes under a set amount automatically.

Countering a Stripe dispute, step by step

  1. 1

    Read the bank's claim, not just the reason label

    On the dispute's details page, open Review the claim details when the bank has supplied documents. The cardholder's own words often tell you exactly what to rebut.

  2. 2

    Try the customer

    If you can reach them, a replacement or store credit sometimes gets the dispute withdrawn. Even so, you still need to submit a response for Stripe to close it in your favor, and keep the emails: they're evidence.

  3. 3

    Open the form and say why the dispute is wrong

    Dispute details Counter dispute

    The first page asks for your argument and the product type. Stripe uses those to show only the evidence fields that fit, so a digital service isn't asked for tracking.

  4. 4

    Upload one file per evidence type

    Combine several documents of the same kind into one multi-page PDF. Keep the total under 4.5 MB, and under 19 pages for Mastercard.

    Watch for: links, audio and video. The bank won't open them. Paste a screenshot of the tracking page rather than the tracking link.

  5. 5

    Submit, then wait

    The status changes to under review. Banks usually take 60 to 75 days to decide, and Stripe emails you the outcome.

Which evidence answers which dispute reason

Stripe shows the reason on every dispute. Answer that claim directly, rather than sending everything you have.

Dispute reason Evidence that addresses it Watch for
Fraudulent (the cardholder says they didn't make it) Matching billing and shipping details, the customer's IP or device, proof they used what they bought, and any earlier undisputed orders. Visa Compelling Evidence 3.0. When a Visa fraud dispute is eligible, Stripe flags it and prefills those fields. Don't edit what it prefilled.
Product not received Carrier tracking showing delivery to the address on the order, with a signature if you have one, or access logs for a digital product. A delivered scan to a different address than the one the customer entered is a weak case. Say so in your argument rather than hiding it.
Product unacceptable or not as described The product description they saw, photos, your return policy as shown at checkout, and the thread where you offered a fix. If they asked for a return and you ignored them, this one's hard to counter.
Subscription canceled or credit not processed Your cancellation and refund terms, proof the customer agreed to them, and logs showing no cancellation request (or a refund already issued). Partial refunds. A customer can dispute the full charge after a partial refund, so show what was already returned.
Duplicate or unrecognized Proof the two charges were for different orders, or the receipt and statement descriptor that tie the charge to your business. An unclear descriptor causes a lot of these. A recognizable name on the card statement prevents the next ones.

How merchants lose disputes they could have won

Ignoring an inquiry

How you'll know: The Dashboard shows an inquiry (the API calls it a warning) rather than a full dispute, and there's no money taken yet.

Fix: Respond anyway. American Express and Discover use inquiries most, and an unanswered inquiry can turn into a chargeback that's close to unwinnable. Answering at this stage costs no dispute fee.

Trying to refund the charge now

How you'll know: You'd rather just give the money back.

Fix: You can't refund outside the dispute while it's open. Accept the dispute instead. Refunds only head off a dispute before it's filed.

Submitting half the evidence on day one

How you'll know: You planned to add the delivery proof later.

Fix: There's no later. The first submission is final, so build the full packet, then send it.

Fewer disputes next quarter

Early fraud warnings. Card issuers flag some payments as likely fraud before any dispute is filed, and Stripe shows those warnings. Stripe's own guidance is that refunding a flagged charge makes sense when it's roughly the size of your dispute fee or smaller. On bigger charges it usually doesn't pay.

Radar. Stripe's fraud screening scores each card payment and blocks the riskiest ones. Teams with a real fraud problem add their own rules on top, for example holding orders where the card country and shipping country differ.

A clear statement descriptor and easy refunds. Many disputes are customers who didn't recognize the charge or couldn't reach you. A name they recognize and a visible way to ask for a refund cost nothing.

Watch the rate, not just the case. Visa and Mastercard both run monitoring programs for merchants whose dispute rate climbs, and they can restrict accounts that stay high. Stripe's dispute monitoring page lists the current thresholds. Treat anything near 1% of transactions as a warning sign.

Questions people ask

What's the difference between a Stripe dispute and a refund?

You start a refund, on your terms, with no fee. A dispute is started by the customer's bank, takes the money straight away, adds a fee, and gives you a deadline to contest it. If you already know a charge is wrong, refunding before the customer goes to their bank avoids all of that.

How much is a Stripe dispute fee?

In the US, a $15 fee when a dispute arrives, which you don't get back, plus a $15 countered fee if you contest it, which is returned if you win. Amounts vary by country and contract, so check Stripe's pricing page for your account.

How long do I have to respond to a Stripe dispute?

Usually 7 to 21 days from the dispute being created, depending on the card network. Your exact due date is on the dispute's details page. Customers themselves generally have up to 120 days after a card payment to file, and longer for things like travel or event tickets paid in advance.

What's a healthy Stripe dispute rate?

As low as you can keep it. Card network monitoring programs start paying attention as a merchant's rate rises toward about 1% of transactions, with thresholds that differ by network and change over time. Track the trend monthly rather than waiting for a warning.

Can I submit Stripe dispute evidence through the API instead of the dashboard?

Yes. The Disputes API takes the same evidence fields and files as the Dashboard form, and you can choose to save it without submitting. That's what lets n-frames build a packet automatically when a dispute opens and leave the final submit to your team.

Can Stripe respond to disputes for me?

Stripe offers Smart Disputes, where it builds and submits the response from your payment data and charges a share of the disputes it wins. It works from what Stripe holds. Delivery proof and customer messages kept in other systems still have to reach Stripe somehow, which is where a custom integration earns its place.

How do I record a lost dispute in my books?

The disputed amount and fee come out of a Stripe payout, so they need their own lines rather than vanishing into net deposits. Our guide to recording a chargeback in QuickBooks walks through it.

Let's talk

Tell us the one thing your team does manually that eats up time. We read every message and reply within a day.