What we do
Tools
Industries
Department
How we workLet's talk →
Home/Industries/Church Management Software That Fits Your Size
Church Management Software

Church Management Software Without Losing a Single Gift Record

Most churches shopping for new software have one quiet worry: that years of membership and giving records won't come across, and that year-end statements will go out wrong. Picking between Planning Center, Breeze, ChurchTrac, Pushpay and Rock RMS matters, but protecting those records matters more. This page covers both.

How giving records get lost in a switch

None of these show up on the day you go live. They show up in January, when a family asks why their statement is short.

The export leaves out contribution history

How you'll know: People and households came across, but older gifts, or gifts to some funds, are missing.

Fix: Before you sign anything, export everything from the old system: people, households, gifts by fund, attendance and volunteer rosters. Some older systems only give you part of it.

A designated fund quietly becomes general giving

How you'll know: Building fund or missions totals in the new system don't match what the treasurer reported last year.

Fix: Map every old fund name to a new one by hand, then compare totals fund by fund before the old system is switched off. Merge duplicate households at the same time; most churches have a few families entered twice.

Statements come from two systems for one year

How you'll know: Givers get two partial statements, or one that's missing the months before the switch.

Fix: Switch at a quiet point in the giving year, not just before statements go out, and run both systems side by side for a few weeks of Sundays.

Which platform suits which kind of church

A first shortlist. How your treasurer tracks designated gifts, and how many volunteers you schedule, matter as much as attendance.

Your church Usually worth a look Test this before you commit
One site, part-time office staff, a tight budget Breeze or ChurchTrac Year-end giving statements. If producing them takes a weekend, that's the feature to test first.
Busy weekend services, lots of volunteer teams, kids check-in Planning Center The total once you add the modules you need. People is free, and the other modules, like Giving, Check-Ins, Services and Groups, are priced separately.
Online and app giving is a priority Pushpay Price and contract terms, which often outweigh the feature gap for a smaller congregation.
Several campuses under one leadership team Planning Center or Pushpay, sometimes with a custom reporting layer Whether giving and attendance roll up across campuses the way leadership reads them. This is the part that most often needs work.
Large church with in-house tech staff Rock RMS It's free and open source, but you host it, update it and own every fix. Budget staff time, not license fees.

Ask these on every church software demo

Bring your treasurer if you can. These are the questions a sales rep with a sample congregation can't answer without trying it.

  • "Record a gift split between the building fund and general giving."

    Then run the report your treasurer actually uses. Designated funds are where reports tend to disagree.

  • "Produce year-end giving statements for every household."

    Ask how long it takes and what it looks like for a family with two givers and one joint gift.

  • "Here's our old export. Who brings in the giving history?"

    Vendors often import people and leave contribution history for you. Ask them to put who does what in the quote.

  • "Show me attendance and giving for all campuses on one screen."

    Only if you're multi-site. If it means one export per campus, plan for that work now.

  • "Schedule a volunteer who serves at two campuses."

    Double-booked volunteers are the first complaint after go-live at multi-site churches.

Where we come in, depending on your starting point

01

Still choosing

We weigh the shortlist against your real attendance, giving patterns and volunteer structure, not a denominational recommendation or a feature grid.

Picking whatever a conference recommended.A shortlist sized to how your church runs.
02

Moving from an old system

We migrate members, households and giving history fund by fund, so a staff member pulling up a family sees their full record on day one.

A decade of giving history left behind.Member and giving records carried over complete.
03

Running several campuses

When campus reporting doesn't roll up the way leadership needs it, we build the cross-campus view so nobody stitches exports together on Monday morning.

One spreadsheet per campus every week.One report across campuses that leadership trusts.
Let's talk

Before you sign with a new vendor, talk to us

Send us what you use today, roughly how many households give, and which funds you track. n-frames maps every one of those funds to the new platform, moves your households and giving history across, and checks the totals against the old system before it's switched off.

Talk through our move →

Questions people ask

Is Pushpay overkill for a smaller single-site congregation?

Often, mainly on price. Breeze or ChurchTrac usually suit a smaller single-site church better, unless app giving and volunteer scheduling are central to how you run.

Can giving and attendance history actually move without gaps?

Yes, if it's mapped carefully and checked against the old totals before cutover. That's the work we do, so staff see a complete history rather than a fresh start.

We run multiple campuses. Does that change which church platform fits?

A lot. Platforms differ most in how volunteer scheduling and giving reports roll up across campuses, and that difference matters more than any single feature on a comparison chart.

Does the software handle recurring and designated giving well?

The major platforms all take recurring gifts. How cleanly a designated gift reports, say building fund versus general giving, varies more. Test it on the demo with the way your treasurer actually tracks funds.

Do we have to migrate our member and giving records ourselves, or does the vendor handle that?

Usually neither does it fully. Vendors support their own platform and may import basic member lists, but moving giving history correctly and building multi-campus reporting is work we take on directly with your team.

How long does switching church management software take?

Choosing takes a couple of weeks once we understand your size and structure. The migration typically takes three to six weeks, depending on how many years of giving history move.

Is there free church management software?

Some. Planning Center People is free, with the other modules priced separately as you grow. Rock RMS is free and open source, but you pay in hosting and staff time. For a small church, a low-cost paid system is often cheaper overall than free software nobody has time to maintain.

Let's talk

Tell us the one thing your team does manually that eats up time. We read every message and reply within a day.