We already run a general ERP. Do we need to replace it?
Not always. Sometimes the fix is adding batch, lot, and shelf-life tracking on top of what you run today instead of a full rip-and-replace. We look at what your current system already does well before recommending you throw it out.
What does food manufacturing ERP actually track that a general ERP doesn't?
Recipe and formula scaling, batch and lot traceability, FEFO allocation by expiration date, allergen tracking, and recall readiness. A general ERP tracks units and work orders; it has no concept of what lot of an ingredient went into a specific batch, which is the thing a recall actually depends on.
Is BatchMaster overkill for a smaller food producer?
Sometimes, yes, depending on production complexity. A smaller operation with simpler recipes and less regulatory exposure might fit better with a lighter platform like Wherefour. We weigh that against your actual audit and recall history, not just your revenue.
How far back does our lot traceability actually need to reach?
That depends on your product category and any audit history you've had. Some categories and customers require tracing an ingredient lot back through multiple production steps; others need less. We size the system to what you're actually required to produce if asked.
Who migrates our existing recipe and lot data into the new system?
We're the ones in the weeds on that. BatchMaster, Wherefour, and Columbus support their own platforms; actually moving your recipes and lot records across without a gap, since a recall depends on that trail, is a project we run start to finish.
Does this apply to co-packers running multiple customers' recipes?
Yes, and it often adds complexity standard modules don't fully anticipate, different allergen protocols or shelf-life rules per customer recipe. When that's the case, we build the tracking logic to match what each customer actually requires.