What we do
Tools
Industries
Department
How we workLet's talk →
Home/GoCardless/Stripe vs GoCardless
Payments comparison

Stripe vs GoCardless: How Do Your Customers Expect to Pay You Each Month?

A client on a $2,400 monthly retainer pays by card, and at Stripe's US card rate of 2.9% + 30¢ about $70 of every payment goes in fees. Another customer's card expired over the weekend, and the renewal bounced. GoCardless pulls from a bank account under a mandate the customer signs once. Stripe charges cards first, but it collects bank debits too, so the split isn't as tidy as cards against banks.

A card on file with Stripe, or a mandate with GoCardless

US list prices from each vendor's pricing page. Both quote other rates by country.

Stripe

Cards first, bank debit as an option

  • Domestic cards at 2.9% + 30¢ per successful payment.
  • ACH Direct Debit at 0.8%, capped at $5.
  • Bank debit schemes outside the US too, such as Bacs in the UK and SEPA in Europe.
  • A card payment confirms in seconds. Cards also expire, get replaced and get declined by fraud checks.
GoCardless

Bank debit is the whole product

  • Standard plan at 0.5% + 5¢, capped at $5. Advanced and Pro cost more per payment and add tools such as Success+ for recovering failed payments.
  • International payments from 1.5% + 5¢. In the UK, Standard is 1% + 20p, capped at £4.
  • A $5 fee for each failed payment, and 50¢ per refund, on the US price list.
  • Local schemes including ACH, Bacs, SEPA and BECS. A new mandate takes a few working days before the first collection.

At a $1,000 invoice both bank-debit options hit their $5 cap, against $29.30 by card. At $200, GoCardless Standard costs $1.05, Stripe ACH $1.60 and a card $6.10. Once you've chosen bank debit, the price gap is small. The bigger choice is whether your customers will sign a mandate at all.

Five things about your customers that pick the payment rail

  • Where do most of your customers bank?

    GoCardless runs on local debit schemes country by country. Customers in the UK and much of Europe know direct debit well. A US consumer checkout is built around a card form.

  • How big is a typical payment?

    Percentage fees hurt most on large payments. Bank-debit caps turn a $1,000 or $5,000 invoice into a flat fee, while a card keeps charging its percentage all the way up.

  • Do you need the money before you deliver?

    A card confirms straight away. A new mandate and its first debit take a few working days, which matters if you ship or switch something on as soon as the first payment clears.

  • Are you billing a retainer or invoice, or selling a consumer subscription?

    A recurring invoice to a business suits a mandate signed once. A card form is quicker for a shopper signing up on your site.

  • What does a failed payment cost you today?

    Card failures come from expiry and fraud checks. Bank debits fail mainly when the account is short or the mandate is cancelled, and GoCardless charges $5 for each failure.

Running Stripe and GoCardless together without double-charging anyone

A customer billed on both rails

How you'll know: Someone moved to direct debit, and their old card subscription in Stripe charged them again the same month.

Fix: Keep one record of which rail each customer pays on. When GoCardless reports a mandate as active, cancel or pause the matching Stripe subscription in the same step.

A mandate cancelled at the bank

How you'll know: The next collection fails because the customer cancelled the direct debit through their own bank.

Fix: Act on GoCardless's mandate-cancelled webhook: pause the plan and send the customer a card payment link from Stripe before the next due date, rather than finding out from the failed payment.

Two payout streams, one set of invoices

How you'll know: The books show invoices paid twice, or not at all, for customers who switched rails mid-year.

Fix: Each processor books its own payouts. Match both streams to the same invoice numbers in your billing or accounting system, so a customer who paid by card in March and by debit in April has one clean history.

Let's talk

Card for some customers, bank debit for others, one set of books

n-frames builds the layer between your billing system and both processors: it records which rail each customer pays on, starts the right collection on each due date, reacts to failed payments and cancelled mandates, and matches Stripe and GoCardless payouts to the same invoices.

Cards and mandates on one invoice trail →

Card fees, debit caps and failed renewals

Is GoCardless cheaper than Stripe?

Than Stripe's card rate, yes, by a wide margin. On US list prices GoCardless Standard is 0.5% + 5¢ capped at $5, against 2.9% + 30¢ for a domestic card on Stripe. Against Stripe's own ACH Direct Debit, at 0.8% capped at $5, the gap is small, and from about $1,000 up both charge the same $5.

Can I use GoCardless and Stripe together for different customers?

Yes. One split that works is bank debit through GoCardless for customers on recurring invoices in markets where direct debit is normal, and Stripe cards for everyone else. The work is making sure each customer is collected on one rail only, and that both sets of payouts land against the same invoices.

Which one is better for international customers paying from abroad?

It depends where they bank. GoCardless covers local schemes such as Bacs, SEPA, ACH and BECS, and charges its international rate when the payment crosses borders. Stripe's cards work almost anywhere a customer has a card, and it runs several local debit schemes itself.

Does GoCardless or Stripe fail less often on recurring payments?

Bank debit avoids the card problems behind many failed renewals: expired cards, replaced cards and fraud-check declines. It has failures of its own, when the account is short or the customer cancels the mandate. GoCardless's Advanced plan adds Success+ to recover failed payments, and Stripe's ACH Direct Debit gets the same card-free benefit on US payments.

Who builds the setup that runs Stripe and GoCardless side by side?

n-frames. We build the piece that decides which rail each customer is collected on, moves a customer from card to mandate without a double charge, falls back to a card link when a mandate is cancelled, and reconciles both payout streams against your invoices.

Let's talk

Tell us the one thing your team does manually that eats up time. We read every message and reply within a day.