What kind of practice are you running?
Common shortlists for each shape of firm. They're places to start, not rankings, and plenty of firms fit two rows.
Your practice Usually shortlisted Find out before you buy
One or two preparers, mostly individual returns Drake or ProSeries, which many smaller offices start on What you pay once volume grows. Ask how pricing changes between a few hundred returns and a few thousand.
Several preparers and a reviewer sharing a client list Any of the four, once you've checked its multi-user setup. Drake, for one, sells a separate Multi-User version for firms with two or more preparers. How a return moves from preparer to reviewer, and what happens when two people open it at once.
Heavy on business, partnership and multi-state returns Lacerte or UltraTax, both built with complex returns in mind Whether your state mix and entity types are covered in the edition you're quoted.
You keep the books for many of your tax clients A package that takes your ledger in cleanly. Lacerte and ProSeries import a trial balance from QuickBooks. UltraTax sits in Thomson Reuters' CS Professional Suite next to its accounting product. Run one real client through the import. Preparers report that mapping a QuickBooks Online export takes more steps than the demo suggests.