What we do
Tools
Industries
Department
How we workLet's talk →
Home/QuickBooks/Gusto vs QuickBooks Payroll, and What Syncs
QuickBooks + Gusto

Gusto vs QuickBooks Payroll: Which to Run, and What Syncs If You Use Both

QuickBooks Payroll runs inside QuickBooks, so paychecks are already in your books. Gusto is separate payroll and HR software that sends a journal entry to QuickBooks Online after each payroll. Either can pay your people well. The difference shows up in your books, and in how much HR you want alongside payroll.

Gusto or QuickBooks Payroll

QuickBooks Payroll

Payroll inside your books

  • Paychecks and payroll taxes post straight into QuickBooks. There's no second system and no sync to check.
  • One login and one bill for books and payroll.
Gusto

Payroll and HR, synced to your books

  • A separate payroll and HR platform, with onboarding, benefits administration and employee self-service around payroll.
  • Posts one journal entry per payroll to QuickBooks Online, mapped to your own accounts.
  • Works with other accounting software too, if you ever leave QuickBooks.

If payroll is just paying people and you live in QuickBooks, QuickBooks Payroll is the simpler setup. If your team wants the HR side, Gusto plus its QuickBooks Online sync works well. Check the mapping section below before you decide.

Does Gusto integrate with QuickBooks?

QuickBooks Online: yes, an official integration. You connect it in Gusto, Gusto reads your chart of accounts, and you map each payroll category to an account. After every payroll it posts a journal entry.

QuickBooks Desktop: no live sync. Gusto creates an IIF file after each payroll, and you import it into Desktop yourself.

What the official Gusto sync already does

Worth knowing before anyone sells you a fix for something Gusto handles.

  • Maps payroll to your own accounts

    Wages, employer taxes, benefits and deductions each go to the QuickBooks account you choose. Every category needs a mapping, even ones you don't use yet.

  • Splits by employee, department, job or Gusto Projects

    Instead of one combined entry, the journal entry can be grouped by any of these, as long as you've set them up in Gusto.

  • Assigns a QuickBooks class

    You can attach a class to each grouping. Gusto supports one class per journal entry, and classes must exist in QuickBooks first, then you refresh accounts in Gusto.

  • Posts contractors separately if you want

    Contractor payments can sync as their own entries rather than inside the payroll entry.

  • Lets you pick the posting date

    Check date or debit date. Pick the one your bank feed will match, or payroll will look out by a day or two at month end.

  • Doesn't rewrite the past

    A mapping change only affects future payrolls. Earlier entries keep the old mapping unless you re-sync them by hand.

Where the sync stops short

Hours by job live in a different tool

How you'll know: Your crews clock time in a field service app or a separate time tracker, and Gusto only knows each person's total hours.

Fix: Gusto can only split wages by the jobs it knows about. Someone ends up dividing the payroll entry by hand from timesheets, which is the step that's worth automating.

You report on several classes in one payroll

How you'll know: Locations or service lines are QuickBooks classes, and one payroll covers people in all of them.

Fix: With one class per journal entry, you need the entry grouped so each part carries its own class, or a sync that writes the lines with their classes. See adding classes in QuickBooks.

Edits in QuickBooks never reach Gusto

How you'll know: Your bookkeeper reclassed part of last month's payroll entry, and Gusto's reports still show the original split.

Fix: Treat Gusto as the source for payroll, and fix mappings there. Corrections made to the posted entry only exist in QuickBooks.

A multi-location business splitting payroll by hand

Multi-location service business · Gusto for payroll, QuickBooks Online for the books

Before

Gusto's journal entry landed as one wage expense each pay period. For a company billing clients by job and by location, that number couldn't show which jobs made money once labor was counted.

Every two weeks someone split the entry across locations in a spreadsheet, working from timesheets that sat in a third system.

After

A sync reads each employee's hours by job and location from the time-tracking tool, matches them to the Gusto payroll run, and posts the entry to QuickBooks already split by the class, department or job the business reports on.

The spreadsheet step went away, and job costing is right on the day payroll runs instead of two weeks later.

Questions people ask

Does Gusto integrate with QuickBooks?

Yes, with QuickBooks Online through an official integration that posts a payroll journal entry after each pay run. With QuickBooks Desktop there's no live sync: Gusto produces an IIF file that you import by hand.

Should I use Gusto or QuickBooks Payroll?

If you want payroll and the books in one place with nothing to sync, QuickBooks Payroll is simpler. If you want onboarding, benefits administration and other HR tools alongside payroll, Gusto usually goes further, and its sync keeps QuickBooks Online up to date with a journal entry each payroll.

Does the Gusto-QuickBooks sync split payroll by department or job?

Yes, if those departments or jobs are set up in Gusto. The entry can be grouped by employee, department, job or Gusto Projects, with one QuickBooks class per entry. Where it stops is labor split by jobs that only your separate time tool knows about.

Is QuickBooks Payroll the same company as Gusto?

No. QuickBooks Payroll is Intuit's own payroll, built into QuickBooks. Gusto is an independent company whose payroll and HR platform connects to QuickBooks Online.

Why does the Gusto journal entry not match my bank feed?

Usually the posting date or the tax lines. Gusto can post on the check date or the debit date, and the bank may pull taxes and wages on different days. Only employer taxes appear on the entry, because employee taxes are withheld out of gross wages rather than being an extra cost to you.

Let's talk

Tell us the one thing your team does manually that eats up time. We read every message and reply within a day.