Recurring tasks arrive as one-off tasks
How you'll know: Your weekly report task shows up once, with no repeat.
Fix: Note each recurring task in Asana before you import, then set its recurrence again in ClickUp.
Both run tasks and projects well. The real split is scope. ClickUp wants to be your docs, whiteboards, chat, time tracker and task list in one workspace. Asana stays focused on tasks and projects and is quicker for a whole company to pick up. Decide how much else this tool has to replace, and who on your team will build it out.
Want to cancel a docs tool, a time tracker or a whiteboard app? Lean ClickUp. Those live inside the same workspace, and time tracking is included from its Core plan.
Need 40 people using it next week with little training? Lean Asana. Fewer setup choices means fewer ways to build a workspace nobody understands.
Nobody on the team wants to own the setup? That points to Asana too. ClickUp rewards someone who enjoys designing spaces, fields and statuses, and punishes a team that skips that step.
A team that keeps asking "where's that doc?" gets more from ClickUp. A team that keeps asking "who owns this?" usually gets there faster on Asana.
ClickUp's Core plan is $9 per user a month billed yearly, or $12 month to month. Business is $17 billed yearly, or $25 monthly, and adds Timeline and Workload views and a bigger automation allowance. Enterprise is priced on request.
Asana's Starter plan is $10.99 per user a month billed yearly, or $13.49 monthly. Advanced is $24.99 billed yearly, or $30.49 monthly.
Seat for seat, ClickUp is usually cheaper. The fairer sum takes off what you'd save by cancelling other apps, and adds the weeks someone spends designing ClickUp's workspace. Neither plan price includes the hours spent copying finished work into invoices and reports, which stays the same on both.
20-person creative agency · chose ClickUp after weeks comparing it with Asana
ClickUp's custom fields held each campaign's status, budget and client approval stage on one task. That part worked.
But every finished campaign meant someone opening the billing system, reading the final budget off the task and building the invoice from nothing.
When a campaign task reaches Client Approved, a draft invoice now appears in their accounting software with the budget and line items taken from the task's fields.
Nobody retypes a figure that already lives in ClickUp.
On Asana the gap would have been the same. Picking the tool settled how work got organized. The connection to billing was separate work.
ClickUp has a built-in Asana importer. Its own help article lists what doesn't come across.
How you'll know: Your weekly report task shows up once, with no repeat.
Fix: Note each recurring task in Asana before you import, then set its recurrence again in ClickUp.
How you'll know: Tasks that only lived in someone's My Tasks, or that were never added to a project, aren't anywhere in ClickUp.
Fix: Have each person move anything they need into a shared project first. The import can only see what the connected account can see.
How you'll know: Old comments read fine, but the people mentioned in them aren't linked or notified.
Fix: Accept it for history. For live work, re-tag people on the open tasks after the move.
How you'll know: Tasks that used to move or reassign on their own now sit still.
Fix: List every rule before you start and recreate each one as a ClickUp automation. Then check the total against your plan's monthly action allowance.
Per seat, ClickUp usually is: Core is $9 per user a month billed yearly against $10.99 for Asana Starter. ClickUp's free plan also allows unlimited members, where Asana's free Personal plan covers 2 users. The gap narrows once you need ClickUp Business for Timeline and Workload views.
ClickUp packs Docs, whiteboards, chat and time tracking into the same workspace, and its AI assistant, ClickUp Brain, comes with credits on each plan. Asana's case is focus rather than feature count: a cleaner task-and-project tool that needs less designing before people use it.
Asana, for most teams. There are fewer structural choices to make before day one. ClickUp is easy to use once someone has set up spaces, statuses and fields well, and confusing when nobody has.
Slightly, and mostly in where the automation runs. Say each approved task should create an invoice and update the CRM. On Asana, n-frames starts that from an Asana rule and does the invoice and CRM steps in a small service it runs. On ClickUp, every step a built-in automation takes counts against the monthly action allowance (1,000 on Core), so on a busy account we keep only the trigger in ClickUp and do the rest in that service, which can keep you on Core rather than Business.
Yes, but there's no one-click route. Export from ClickUp to CSV and use Asana's CSV importer, then rebuild automations, Docs and anything that relied on ClickUp-only views by hand or with a script.