Why is my beginning balance off in QuickBooks?
Nearly always because a transaction from an already-reconciled month was edited, deleted or added later. The beginning balance is rebuilt from reconciled items, so that one change carries forward. The warning on the Reconcile screen lists which transactions changed.
How do I enter a beginning balance for a new account in QuickBooks Online?
When you add the account in the chart of accounts, QuickBooks asks for a balance and the date it applies to, and posts it against Opening Balance Equity. Forgot, or got it wrong? Edit or add the opening balance entry in the account's register afterwards, as in the steps above.
Can I change the beginning balance shown when reconciling if I'm sure the statement is wrong?
No, and forcing it would hide a real problem. If you believe the bank's statement is wrong, take it up with the bank and get a corrected statement. QuickBooks should only ever match what the bank actually reports.
How do I fix a beginning balance discrepancy in QuickBooks Desktop?
Same cause, same fix. In Desktop, run the Reconciliation Discrepancy report from the Banking reports for that account. It lists reconciled transactions that were changed or deleted and the effect each change had on the balance.
Does changing the opening balance affect my profit and loss?
No. The other side of an opening balance entry is Opening Balance Equity, a balance sheet account, so income and expenses don't move. What it can change is every reconciliation that starts from that entry.