What you have now How it gets to Shopify What goes wrong if nobody plans it
Products, variants, images and descriptions CSV export and import, or a migration app. Usually the easy part. Options that were set up differently on the old platform (a size chart in the description, a custom field for color) arrive as loose text instead of real variants.
Customer records Imported with names, addresses and marketing consent. Passwords can't come across, because Shopify can't read the old platform's password hashes. Accounts arrive inactive, and customers need an account invite to set a new password.
Order history Imported as past orders tied to each customer, with a migration app or a script. Skipped entirely, so a returning customer sees an empty order history and support can't look up last year's purchase.
Product, category and content URLs Redirected one by one, because Shopify uses its own fixed paths such as /products/ and /collections/. Rankings built over years point to a 404 page, and search traffic drops in the weeks after launch.
Accounting, email, inventory and fulfillment connections Repointed at the new store, or replaced where the old app has no Shopify version. Orders stop reaching QuickBooks or NetSuite, stock counts drift, and nobody notices until month-end.