What we do
Tools
Industries
Department
How we workLet's talk →
Home/BigCommerce/BigCommerce vs Shopify
BigCommerce vs Shopify

BigCommerce vs Shopify: The Numbers That Decide It Have Changed

Most comparisons still say BigCommerce charges no transaction fees and Shopify does. That's no longer true. BigCommerce renamed its plans to Core, Growth, Scale and Performance, lowered the yearly sales caps on each, and added a fee when you use a payment provider outside its own list. The choice now turns on four numbers from your own store. Pull them first.

Four numbers to have in front of you

  • Your online sales over the last twelve months

    BigCommerce plans are capped by sales: Core up to $30K and Growth up to $100K over the trailing twelve months, after which you move up a plan. Shopify plans aren't capped by sales, so a fast-growing store pays the same plan price as it grows.

  • Which payment processor you want to keep

    Both now charge extra for a provider outside their own. Shopify adds 2% on Basic, 1% on Grow and 0.6% on Advanced unless you use Shopify Payments. BigCommerce adds 2%, 1% and 0.6% on Core, Growth and Scale for providers outside its embedded list. If you're tied to a processor, check it against BigCommerce's list, and ask whether purchase-order and offline payments count.

  • How much of your revenue is wholesale

    Shopify includes B2B (company accounts, wholesale pricing, catalogs) on Basic, Grow and Advanced, with up to three active catalog assignments below Shopify Plus. BigCommerce has customer groups from Growth up, but price lists for customer-specific pricing are on Performance only.

  • How many storefronts or brands you run

    BigCommerce sells multi-storefront as an add-on on Core, Growth and Scale, up to 3, 5 and 8 storefronts, all from one catalog and one admin. If you run several brands off shared stock, that's a real point in its favor.

Selling wholesale on each, week to week

BigCommerce

More product depth in the core

  • Product options and variants go further before you need an app.
  • Customer groups for trade buyers from the Growth plan up.
  • Per-customer, SKU-level price lists only on Performance, so a mid-size wholesaler may face a big jump.
  • Several storefronts on one catalog through the multi-storefront add-on.
Shopify

Bigger ecosystem, B2B on most plans

  • Company profiles, wholesale pricing and B2B ordering on Basic, Grow and Advanced.
  • Limits below Plus: up to three active catalog assignments, and no assigning a catalog directly to one company.
  • By far the larger app store and theme library, so most gaps already have an app.
  • Those apps add monthly fees, so list the ones you'd need before comparing totals.

A handful of trade accounts on one price list: Shopify's B2B on a standard plan usually covers it. Hundreds of accounts each with their own pricing, or several brands from one warehouse: price BigCommerce's Performance plan or multi-storefront, and Shopify Plus, side by side.

What neither platform settles: stock and the books

Both platforms take the order well. What happens next is the same gap on each: wholesale orders on terms need invoices in your accounting system, stock needs to come off the shared count in the warehouse system, and a rep's phone order needs to land in the store without being retyped. Connectors cover the simple version and leave the wholesale terms, partial shipments and returns for someone to fix by hand.

n-frames builds that layer through the BigCommerce and Shopify APIs: B2B orders posted to the books with their terms, inventory kept in step across storefronts and channels, and fulfillment started without a person in the middle. More on the BigCommerce and Shopify side, on BigCommerce B2B Edition and on Shopify B2B and wholesale.

Questions people ask

Does BigCommerce charge transaction fees?

Now it does, in one case. Orders through a provider on BigCommerce's embedded list carry no BigCommerce fee. Orders through any other provider carry an Open Payment Provider fee of 2% on Core, 1% on Growth and 0.6% on Scale, and Performance terms are set by contract. That mirrors Shopify's extra fee for not using Shopify Payments.

Which has a bigger app ecosystem?

Shopify, by a wide margin, in both apps and themes. BigCommerce builds more into the core platform, product options especially, so you need fewer apps to start with.

Which is better for B2B selling?

It depends on how many trade accounts you have and how they're priced. Shopify now offers B2B on Basic, Grow and Advanced with catalog limits, and lifts them on Plus. BigCommerce offers customer groups from Growth and SKU-level price lists on Performance, plus its separate B2B Edition. Count your accounts and price lists before you choose.

Do BigCommerce plans have sales limits?

Yes. Core covers up to $30K and Growth up to $100K of online sales over the trailing twelve months. Pass that and BigCommerce moves you to the next plan. Scale charges an overage above its monthly level and moves you to Performance at higher volumes.

Inventory and accounting still don't sync on our store platform. Do we need to switch to fix it?

No. Neither BigCommerce nor Shopify keeps a warehouse count and the books in step on its own, so a new platform brings the same gap. n-frames builds the sync on the platform you're already on.

Let's talk

Tell us the one thing your team does manually that eats up time. We read every message and reply within a day.