Stripe vs PayPal: Which to Use, and When to Offer Both
Stripe charges less per card payment and gives you more control over checkout and billing. PayPal costs more per payment, but it brings a button plenty of shoppers already trust, plus Venmo and Pay Later. Many online businesses end up running both. Here's how to decide, using the US rates from each company's own fee pages.
Pick Stripe if you're building your own checkout, billing subscriptions or running a marketplace. Its US rate for online payments on domestic cards is 2.9% + 30¢.
Add PayPal if a real share of your buyers would rather log in to PayPal than type a card number. Its US rate when a buyer pays with PayPal or Venmo is 3.49% + 49¢.
Run both if you sell online to consumers. Stripe takes the card form and PayPal sits next to it as a second button.
Neither one fixes the bookkeeping. Two processors means two sets of payouts, fees and refunds to match back to orders.
Where Stripe and PayPal actually part ways
Stripe: you shape the checkout
- Prebuilt Checkout and Payment Links, or a payment form built into your own site or app.
- Subscriptions with trials, proration and usage pricing through Stripe Billing, which is priced as its own product.
- Connect for marketplaces and platforms that pay out to sellers.
- Surcharges on top of the base rate: 0.5% for cards typed in by hand, 1.5% for cards issued outside the US, and 1% when a currency gets converted.
PayPal: buyers already have an account
- Shoppers pay with a saved PayPal login, Venmo or Pay Later, without typing a card.
- Buyer protection is a big reason people click the button, and it means disputes run through PayPal's Resolution Center.
- PayPal invoices and payment buttons go live with no code at all.
- Money lands in a PayPal balance first, then moves to your bank.
If you can only set up one, most online businesses get more from Stripe for cards and add the PayPal button once buyers start asking for it. A freelancer sending a few invoices a month can start on either.
One $80 order, charged both ways
Same sale, same US customer, no currency conversion. The only change is which button they pressed.
| Order total | $80.00 |
|---|---|
| Stripe fee, card at 2.9% + 30¢ (You keep $77.38) | − $2.62 |
| PayPal fee, PayPal button at 3.49% + 49¢ (You keep $76.72) | − $3.28 |
| Extra cost of the PayPal button on this order | $0.66 |
At 1,000 orders like this a month, that's about $660. It's worth paying if the button wins sales you'd otherwise lose, which is something to test rather than assume. PayPal's own card processing costs less than its button, and the rate depends on which PayPal checkout product you use, so check PayPal's US fee page for that figure.
Five questions that settle it for your business
Do you charge on a schedule: memberships, retainers, software seats?
Stripe Billing handles trials, plan changes and proration in more detail. PayPal does recurring payments too, with less control over the awkward cases.
Will a developer build or look after your checkout?
Without one, Stripe Payment Links and PayPal buttons both work with no code. With one, Stripe's API leaves far more room to build the flow you want.
How often do buyers ask to pay with PayPal or Venmo?
If people email to ask, the missing button is already losing you sales. If nobody ever asks, it may be a fee you don't need yet.
Do you sell to customers outside the US?
Stripe adds 1.5% for cards issued abroad and 1% for conversion. PayPal lists its own cross-border and conversion charges on its fee page. Compare them on your real customer mix.
Who reconciles payouts today, and how long does it take?
Every processor you add is another payout schedule and another set of fees to book. Count that time before you add a second one.
Running Stripe and PayPal side by side
For consumer sales online this is where most stores land: Stripe runs the card form and the PayPal button sits beside it. n-frames doesn't sell or resell either processor, so we have no stake in which one you pick. Customers get their choice. You get two payout schedules, two fee structures, two places refunds come from and two separate dispute processes.
Both connect to QuickBooks, and Stripe's payout reconciliation report and PayPal's activity downloads each show what went into a transfer. What neither does is tie its own payments to the orders in your store or CRM next to the other processor's. That's the part n-frames builds: one feed that matches every Stripe charge and every PayPal payment to its order, books the fees and refunds where they belong, and flags anything left over. There's more on the Stripe and PayPal side, and on Stripe webhook setup if you're wiring Stripe events into your own system.
Questions people ask
Is Stripe cheaper than PayPal?
On list price for US online payments, yes. Stripe charges 2.9% + 30¢ on a domestic card. PayPal charges 3.49% + 49¢ when the buyer pays with PayPal or Venmo. PayPal's card processing is priced below its button, so the real gap depends on how your customers choose to pay. Both companies change their rates, so check Stripe's pricing and PayPal's US business fees against your own volume, and see our PayPal fees breakdown.
Can I run Stripe and PayPal at the same time?
Yes, and many stores do. Stripe processes cards through your checkout and PayPal appears as a second way to pay. The cost is on the back office: two sets of payouts and fees, which need matching to the same orders.
Is Stripe or PayPal better for a subscription business?
Usually Stripe. Its Billing product handles custom pricing, trials, proration and plan changes with more control, and it's priced separately from payments. PayPal supports recurring billing but gives you less say over the edge cases. Our Stripe subscriptions guide covers what Billing does once it's live.
Do I need a developer to use either one?
Not to get started. Stripe Payment Links and hosted Checkout, and PayPal's buttons and invoices, all work without code. You need a developer when you want the payment inside your own site or app, or want other systems to react when a payment clears.
What does a dispute cost on each?
On Stripe in the US, a dispute costs $15 when you receive it, and another $15 if you counter it manually, which you get back if you win. PayPal sets its own chargeback and dispute fees on its US fee page. On both, the fee is small next to losing the sale, so having the order and delivery proof to hand matters more.
We're happy with Stripe or PayPal, but reconciliation still eats hours every period. Do we need to switch processors?
Almost never. The hours go into matching payouts to orders and books, and that happens on Stripe and PayPal alike. Switching moves the problem, it doesn't remove it. Our Stripe and QuickBooks and PayPal and QuickBooks guides show what each connector covers and what's left.