Card tapped, dipped or swiped in person
- Square Free: 2.6% + 15¢
- Square Plus: 2.5% + 15¢
- Square Premium: 2.4% + 15¢
- Stripe Terminal: 2.7% + 5¢ on domestic cards
- Stripe Tap to Pay on a phone: add 10¢ per authorization
Square is a ready-made point of sale: buy a reader, open the app, start selling. Stripe is a payments platform your website or app is built on, and its card readers need software around them. So the first question is where your customers pay, not which logo is cheaper. The US rates below come from each company's own pricing page.
Square. The POS app, item catalog and staff tools come with it.
Stripe. A lower online card rate than Square Free, and deeper billing tools.
Often both: Square in the shop, Stripe on the website.
Square's rates drop on its paid plans, which charge a monthly fee per location. Stripe's standard pricing has no monthly fee. Both change their prices from time to time.
Stripe's in-person fixed fee is 5¢ against Square's 15¢, while Square Free's percentage is a tenth of a point lower. On a domestic card the two cost exactly the same on a $100 sale. Below that, Stripe Terminal takes less. Above it, Square Free does. On Square Plus, the crossover drops to $50.
Example: a coffee shop with a $7 average ticket pays about 33¢ a sale on Square Free and about 24¢ on Stripe Terminal. That gap is real at volume, but it only counts if you have software to run Stripe's readers. Square's POS app comes with the account. On Stripe, someone builds the register or you pay for a POS app built on Stripe.
How you'll know: The readers arrived, and there's no till: no item buttons, no staff logins, no end-of-day report.
Fix: Stripe Terminal needs a point-of-sale app built on top of it, your own or a partner's. If you want to sell at a counter next week, that's Square's home ground.
How you'll know: Online orders now cost 3.3% + 30¢ each, and nobody has looked at the plan since launch.
Fix: Set the paid plan's monthly fee per location against 0.4% of your monthly online card volume. Past that point, the plan pays for itself.
How you'll know: The shop sells the last one on Square while the Stripe-powered website still shows it in stock.
Fix: Square's own online store shares the item library with the register. A Stripe checkout on your website doesn't, so stock and orders need a connection between the two.
How you'll know: Square and Stripe deposits arrive on their own schedules, each net of fees and refunds, and the bookkeeper sorts them by guesswork.
Fix: Break every payout into sales, fees and refunds per channel before it's booked, so each deposit ties back to what it paid for.
n-frames builds the link between the two: stock that stays right at the counter and on the website, and every Square and Stripe payout split into sales, fees and refunds in QuickBooks or whichever accounting system you run.
Cost out my two-channel setup →It depends where the card is. In person, Square Free charges 2.6% + 15¢ and Stripe Terminal 2.7% + 5¢, so Stripe costs less on sales under $100 and Square costs less above it. Online, Stripe's 2.9% + 30¢ beats Square Free's 3.3% + 30¢ and matches Square's paid plans. Square includes the POS app, and on Stripe you'd pay to build or buy one. Both sell their readers as a one-off purchase. Check Square's fees and Stripe's pricing for today's numbers.
Yes. Square has its own online store, invoices and online checkout, and the store shares the item library with your register. It's less flexible than Stripe for a fully custom checkout, and on Square Free its online card rate is higher.
Stripe. Stripe Billing has more control over custom pricing, trials, proration and plan changes, and it's priced as a separate product. Square supports recurring payments as well, with less fine-grained control.
Yes, Stripe Terminal readers, and Tap to Pay lets a compatible phone take contactless cards for an extra 10¢ per authorization. The difference is the software: Square's readers come with a full POS app, while Stripe's need an app built on Stripe Terminal. Our Square POS guide covers Square's hardware options.
Yes. Products and customer lists export easily. Saved cards and running subscriptions are the hard part, because card details can't simply be exported to a spreadsheet and re-imported. Plan that piece before you commit to a move.
Probably not, and a switch would cost you something real: Square's POS, staff tools and item library would all need replacing at the counter. Stripe payouts also arrive net of fees and refunds, so the matching work comes along with you. Our Square and QuickBooks guide and Stripe and QuickBooks guide cover what each connector handles and what's still manual. There's more on the Square and Stripe pages.