How your team works Usually fits Check before you commit
Construction, engineering or facilities: schedules, budgets and resources in rows Smartsheet Resource Management is an add-on on Business and Enterprise, not included on Pro. Price it in if capacity planning is the reason you're buying.
Marketing, creative or product: requests, reviews and handoffs between people Asana Timeline and Gantt start on Starter. Portfolios and goals for managers watching many projects start on Advanced.
A PMO reporting across dozens of projects to leadership Either, at the higher tiers Smartsheet portfolios sit on Enterprise and Advanced Work Management. Asana portfolios sit on Advanced. Compare the tier you'd really need, not the entry plan.
Teams that already run everything in Excel Smartsheet It feels like a spreadsheet, so adoption is quick. Watch that it doesn't become one big sheet nobody else can follow.
A small team, just starting to organize work Asana Asana Personal, the free plan, stops at 2 users. Smartsheet has no free plan, only a 30-day trial.