What we do
Tools
Industries
Department
How we workLet's talk →
Home/Smartsheet/Smartsheet vs Asana
Smartsheet vs Asana

Smartsheet vs Asana: Is Your Project a Grid of Numbers, or a Chain of Tasks?

Look at how your team tracks a project today. If it's columns of budget, hours, dates and percent complete, with formulas tying rows together, that's Smartsheet's home ground. If it's work passed from one person to the next, each piece with an owner and a due date, that's Asana's. Most teams already know which picture they're in. The table below confirms it.

Which teams tend to land where

How your team works Usually fits Check before you commit
Construction, engineering or facilities: schedules, budgets and resources in rows Smartsheet Resource Management is an add-on on Business and Enterprise, not included on Pro. Price it in if capacity planning is the reason you're buying.
Marketing, creative or product: requests, reviews and handoffs between people Asana Timeline and Gantt start on Starter. Portfolios and goals for managers watching many projects start on Advanced.
A PMO reporting across dozens of projects to leadership Either, at the higher tiers Smartsheet portfolios sit on Enterprise and Advanced Work Management. Asana portfolios sit on Advanced. Compare the tier you'd really need, not the entry plan.
Teams that already run everything in Excel Smartsheet It feels like a spreadsheet, so adoption is quick. Watch that it doesn't become one big sheet nobody else can follow.
A small team, just starting to organize work Asana Asana Personal, the free plan, stops at 2 users. Smartsheet has no free plan, only a 30-day trial.

What you get on each, and what it costs

Prices are per paid user a month, billed yearly, with the monthly-billing price in brackets.

Rows and columns

Smartsheet

  • Every project is a sheet: rows of work, columns of data, formulas and links across sheets. Gantt, board and calendar views on every plan.
  • Pro is $9 ($12) for 1 to 10 members, with 250 automations a month. Business is $19 ($24) for 3 or more members, with unlimited automations, Timeline view and workload tracking.
  • Resource Management as an add-on from Business. Enterprise and Advanced Work Management priced on request.
Tasks with owners

Asana

  • Every project is a set of tasks with an assignee, due date, subtasks and dependencies, viewed as a list, board, calendar or timeline.
  • Personal costs nothing for up to 2 users. Starter is $10.99 ($13.49), with Timeline and Gantt and unlimited automations. Advanced is $24.99 ($30.49), with portfolios, goals and workload.
  • Numbers live in custom fields on each task, but it doesn't work cell by cell like a spreadsheet.

If your weekly meeting is about whether the numbers add up, Smartsheet. If it's about who's holding up what, Asana.

Moving between Smartsheet and Asana: what catches teams

Formulas arrive as plain values

How you'll know: A Smartsheet budget moved to Asana shows numbers, but nothing recalculates when a date or cost changes.

Fix: List the formulas and cross-sheet links that matter before you move. Some become Asana custom fields, and the real calculations may need to live in a report or a connected sheet instead.

Hierarchy flattens out

How you'll know: Parent rows and child rows from Smartsheet arrive as one long list, or Asana subtasks arrive in Smartsheet with no indent.

Fix: Decide up front which level becomes a project, a section or a task, and reshape the export to match before importing.

Owners come across as names, not people

How you'll know: Every task or row arrives with the right name in it, but nobody is actually assigned.

Fix: Both tools match people by email address. Swap names for work emails in the file before you import.

Automations and alerts stay behind

How you'll know: Reminders and status changes that used to happen on their own have stopped.

Fix: Write down every workflow and alert in the old tool before cutover, and rebuild each one as a rule in the new one.

Where project data goes next, whichever you pick

Smartsheet and Asana both know when a phase is done, how many hours went into it and what's behind. Neither tells your billing system, your CRM or the client. So someone exports a sheet, rebuilds the numbers in a deck, and types hours into invoices.

n-frames connects either one to the rest of the business: approved hours passed to billing, finished milestones updating the CRM, and a status roll-up built from live project data and sent on schedule. See what that looks like on Smartsheet integrations and Asana integrations, and if you're still choosing tools, compare Trello vs Asana or Wrike vs Asana.

Questions people ask

Is Smartsheet better for resource planning than Asana?

Generally, yes. Its grid lends itself to detailed capacity planning, and Resource Management is available as an add-on from the Business plan. Asana's workload view on Advanced covers lighter needs, inside a portfolio.

Is Asana easier to learn than Smartsheet?

For most people, yes, especially anyone who doesn't think in spreadsheets. Smartsheet is quicker for teams that already live in Excel, because it looks and behaves like one.

Can I migrate from Smartsheet to Asana, or the other way around?

Yes. Both import spreadsheet files, so a Smartsheet export to Excel or an Asana project export to CSV can be brought across. Formulas, hierarchy, assignees and automations need extra care, as the list above shows.

Does Smartsheet have a free plan like Asana?

No. Smartsheet offers a 30-day free trial instead. Asana does have a free plan, with the user limit listed above.

Our tool works, but project data doesn't reach the rest of our business. Do we need to switch to Smartsheet or Asana?

Switching won't close that gap, because neither one sends project data to billing or your CRM by itself. A connection from the tool you have to the systems that need its data will.

Let's talk

Tell us the one thing your team does manually that eats up time. We read every message and reply within a day.